DIY Marketing vs. Hiring a Pro: Which Path Is Right for Your Small Business?

So, you’ve hit that crossroads every small business owner faces: Should you dive into marketing yourself or bring in a pro to help out? It’s a question that has crossed the mind of nearly every small business owner.  After all, marketing is that special ingredient that can take your brand from good to amazing or turn a small idea into something truly special. But, as anyone who’s been in the trenches will tell you, it also comes with a pretty hefty to-do list.  In this article, I’m here to walk you through the pros and cons of both paths—whether you decide to tackle marketing on your own or bring in an expert. By the end, you’ll not only have a clearer idea of which route feels right for you, but you might also pick up a few handy tips and bright ideas along the way. Let’s dive in together and figure this out, shall we?

The Perks of Doing Your Own Marketing

1. Cost Savings You Can’t Ignore

Let’s start with the obvious—doing your own marketing is easier on the wallet. When you’re running a small business, every penny counts, and skipping out on hiring a marketer can save you a lot of those precious pennies. It’s tempting to think, “Hey, I can figure this out, right?” And you absolutely can—especially if your budget is tight.

2. You’re the Boss

One of the things I love about handling your own marketing is the control you have. You get to make all the decisions, from the big-picture strategy down to the tiniest details. Want to post something fun and offbeat on your social media? Go for it! You’ve got the freedom to experiment, try new things, and make changes whenever you want.

3. Your Personal Touch Shines Through

No one knows your business like you do. When you’re the one crafting your marketing messages, you can infuse them with your personality and your passion. It’s like you’re having a direct conversation with your customers, which can be incredibly powerful. After all, people connect with people, not just brands.

The Challenges of Going Solo

1. Time, Time, Time

Here’s the thing—marketing takes time. And when you’re already wearing all the hats in your business, adding “Chief Marketing Officer” to your title can be a bit overwhelming. I know how it feels to try to squeeze in a social media post between meetings or to stay up late trying to figure out SEO. It can be done, but it’s a lot to juggle.

2. The Learning Curve Is Real

Marketing is a vast and ever-changing field. From social media algorithms to Google rankings, there’s a lot to keep up with. If you’re new to this, the learning curve can feel steep. It’s like trying to learn a new language while running a marathon—again, it's doable but challenging.

3. Consistency Is Key

It’s easy to kick off your DIY marketing with a bang, but keeping the momentum going? That’s a different ball game. Without a solid strategy in place, those consistent posts can quickly become few and far between, leading to missed opportunities. It’s tough to stay on top of your marketing game when you’ve got a million other things demanding your attention.

Why Bringing in a Pro Could Be a Game-Changer

1. Expertise You Can Count On

One of the biggest perks of a marketing professional is that you’re bringing in someone who lives and breathes this stuff. They’ve got the experience, ideas, and know-how to create strategies that work. It’s like having a personal trainer for your brand—they’ll push you in the right direction and help you reach your goals faster.

2. Time to Focus on What You Love

When you hand off your marketing to someone else, it frees you up to focus on what you’re really passionate about—whether that’s perfecting your product, growing your business, connecting with customers, or just taking a well-deserved break, outsourcing your marketing can give you more time to do what you love.

3. A Consistent and Polished Approach

A good marketer will make sure your brand is consistent across all platforms, from your website to your social media. They’ll help you create a polished image that reflects the best of what your business has to offer, and they’ll keep the ball rolling even when you’re too busy to think about it.

The Downsides of Hiring Out

1. It Can Cost You

Let’s be honest—hiring a marketing professional isn’t cheap. It’s an investment, and depending on your budget, it might feel like a big one. The right marketer can help you grow your business, but you need to be ready to invest in that growth.

2. Letting Go of Control

When you bring in a pro, you’re giving up a bit of control. You have to trust them to understand your vision and represent your brand the way you want. Finding the right fit is crucial, and it might take a little time to find someone who gets you and your business.

3. Finding “The One”

Not all marketing professionals or agencies are created equal. Finding someone who really understands your business and aligns with your values can be a bit like dating—it takes time to find the right match. But when you do, it’s worth it.

If you’re ready to take the plunge into DIY marketing, here are some tips to help you succeed:

Start Small: Don’t try to do it all. Pick one or two platforms where your audience hangs out and start there. Quality over quantity, folks!

Invest in Learning: Take the time to learn the basics of marketing. There are tons of free resources out there—blogs, webinars, online courses. Knowledge is power!

Stay Consistent: Create a content calendar to keep your marketing efforts organized and on track, and try to stick to it. It might be challenging, but it’s worth it.  Consistency builds trust, and trust builds customers.

Leverage Tools: There’s a tool for everything these days! Use design platforms like Canva, scheduling tools like Buffer, and analytics tools like Google Analytics to keep things running smoothly.

Analyze and Adjust: Marketing is part art, part science. Keep an eye on your results, and don’t be afraid to tweak your strategy if something isn’t working.

Keep Social Media Fun, Let the Pros Handle the Rest: 

If you love chatting with your audience and want to keep that personal touch, why not handle your organic social media yourself? It’s a great way to keep your brand’s voice genuine. But when it comes to the more technical stuff—like paid ads, search engine marketing, or optimizing your website—it might be worth bringing in a pro. They can handle the heavy lifting, so you can focus on what you do best. - Stacy Edgar, Saving Grace Marketing

So, should you DIY your marketing, hire a pro, or both? There’s no one-size-fits-all answer, but the good news is you’ve got options. Whether you decide to go it alone or bring in an expert, the key is to make an informed choice that aligns with your business goals. Marketing is your business’s voice—make sure it’s saying what you want it to say. And remember, you don’t have to figure it all out by yourself. There are resources, tools, and talented professionals out there ready to help you shine.

If this blog gave you some food for thought, don’t miss out on future posts! Sign up for our blog updates, and let’s keep the marketing conversation going. We’re here to help you navigate the wild world of marketing, one step at a time.

Sign Up For Our Blog Updates